Taking a closer look, they probably want him as the right-handed half of a platoon with Joc Pederson at DH and a bench bat.
So the carry on which he got hurt wouldn't count? (I'm not sure that is accurate. I thought he got hurt coming out of his stance and never got the...
I know people don't like the guy, but Antonio Brown needs to be on the list. He was the best receiver in the NFL for five or six seasons and is...
Highsmith has played a full season at an elite level. I'm not sure Herbig has even played an entire game at that level.
He was pulled from his one start in Philly with the injury. The injury derailed his shot in Cleveland. You want that "I told you so" so badly...
Just because he signed a minor-league deal doesn't mean he won't be in the majors when the season starts. I assume the Rangers think he at least...
He used to show up and watch local high school baseball games when he lived in Westmoreland County. I met him a couple of times when he was doing...
The Pirates were 20 games under .500 with a putrid offense in 2025. The middle of the lineup should be better with Ozuna, O'Hearn, and Lowe, but...
He is 19. I'm not sure it makes sense to rush him. For once, they might have good reason to wait on bringing up a top prospect.
Mine starts early. It's a slow auction, which takes a few weeks, so we already started.
They didn't have to throw any money at him for two more years, at least no more than Fields cost them. The Eagles brought him in to back up...
Nope. You did not get that right. Where did I say Pickett should be judged positively based on one particular pass? Where did you get that...
Part of the problem is that Herbig does get hurt. I think there is still a significant drop-off from Highsmith to Herbig. The latter makes a...
They aren't getting Mac Jones for 'lower-round picks." He isn't expensive. The 49ers don't have to trade him, so they don't have to take a...
That is not how you phrased it. You listed younger and cheaper separately, then consistency. Herbig is not consistent at all. When he starts, he...
Forget two years ago. They would have done well trading him rather than giving him the monster extension last year.
No, I don't think they got enough, but he realized they weren't going to pay him and wanted out, so they accommodated him.
Fields had stretches when he played far better in Chicago than he ever did in Pittsburgh. He couldn't do it consistently. That Rodgers was...
I'll take that maybe as an admission that you did. Missing one particular pass tells us nothing.
Herbig is not more consistent. He disappears more often than Highsmith.
