Yes. They are both bad at it.
I don't know why you keep trying to pretend that saying Najee is bad at something is the same as saying Warren is good at something. I agree that...
See the post I just made above. EPA per play is also better. And YPC is essentially the same (4.0 vs 3.9). Which is what I said. The per-play...
And the success rate is much higher. Suggests they are being more efficient, but still aren't getting the big plays that drive YPC up. This...
Thanks for the reminder! Week 16 Predictions (Steelers @Lions) 1. Will the Steelers win? No 2. Will the Steelers cover the +7 pts. spread? No 3....
I think we're technically a little bit better at running the ball this year (I would agree that we still aren't good at it though). But the...
Felt, you've finally realized why paying RBs isn't a good idea in the NFL!!! Run success rate isn't a W/L stat. Just like yards isn't a W/L...
I think if you're going to make the claim that this matters, then I think you've got a bunch of work to do to prove it. Would results meaningfully...
You're using information from beyond Edmund's 5th season and comparing it to Najee's first 5 years. We don't know what will happen with Najee in...
What do you think the word subjective means? Note: the antonym is objective (the adjective, not the noun). If succ% is subjective, how is it that...
The UFA market showed that real-life NFL teams valued Najee more than Edmunds. But not by much.
I'll give Kenny the benefit of the doubt. He doesn't have much else at this point IMO. Either way, it was a great catch by Najee.
If you want to argue that neither are starting RBs but you'd prefer Najee if contracts were the same (money and structure), I don't think that's...
Remember that Najee's only in year 5. And he's been on more teams than Edmonds' was at this point in his career. Although that's only because no...
They aren't good ones anyway. And I did answer your questions. Even though I think you're not asking them in good faith. I don't think you...
Good to know the context. I didn't mind Edmunds. He was consistent and available. Certainly not a world beater. But decent as the...
I get this. I think it's a disappointment that he didn't earn a 2nd contract. But I think it's about what you'd expect from a late first round RB....
He was better. But I wouldn't say much better. After he left Edmunds could only get a vet minimum contract. Najee got a little more than that. So...
Sure. And neither of them (Najee or Warren) can perform that role to the level of an average to above-average RB. This is why Najee lost his...
I wouldn't call Najee a failed 1st round pick. But he was certainly a disappointment relative to where he was drafted. He's the RB version of a...
