PWP, that simply isn't true. By all reports, he was a second-rounder at best on most teams' boards.
You still aren't getting it. It's not about evaluating the individual player. It's about getting the most value out of the entire draft. If you...
There are two separate arguments here. One is whether or not Edmunds would have lasted until the Steelers' picks in the second or third round. I...
That had me confused at first, too. :lolol:
That is a fair point. I disagree, but it's fair. My issue is with the posters saying it doesn't matter if they could have gotten Edmunds in the...
I explained why your Brady example doesn't work. There is a huge difference between a first-round pick and a sixth rounder. The correct way to...
Dri Archer was a running back, not a receiver.
I want to join a fantasy baseball league with some of you guys. While you take perfectly good players like Starling Marte and Eddie Rosario in the...
One of the many problems with your Brady example is the huge difference between a first-round pick and a six. It's a silly example to cover for a...
No, I don't act as if he has always been garbage. I gave an accurate representation of his career, far more accurate than your representation of...
There is a reason that regime didn't last long.
Hmmmm...is it better to have just a great player or a first-round pick and the great player. Clearly the latter is better. That is the part that...
So you're going to just define the modern era as whatever you think fits your argument? Sorry, but that's crap. Also, it is a big deal when you...
It is going to be Washington unless his preseason is a disaster. Hunter is a fall-back at best. Heyward-Bey is a No. 4 at best.
I can't believe this is even a discussion. Of course it is a mistake to take a player too early in the draft. Even if that player turns out to be...
Those are enough examples to show it wasn't correct to say that there were only three examples of teams winning without elite quarterbacks. There...
McDonald started seven of the 10 regular season games in which he played. There were games they both started last season. When the season was on...
First, see what Wack Watt wrote. This is a completely different situation from Green's. Second, you are dead wrong on this one. He's the...
Doug Washington? Do you mean Doug Williams? Also, I'm wondering what Watt Wack is defining as the modern era.
The Cowboys were better. They had a better offensive line. They had better offensive weapons, especially Smith at running back. They had a better...
