Do I think the Steelers would have won the Super Bowl with Darnold? No. Do I think they could have at least won a playoff game and given them a...
So no, he isn't the reason they won, so that comparison doesn't work.
You think Darnold was the reason they won. Man, the Steelers really were stupid for not making him a valid offer.
The Steelers were 8-8 in Cowher's final season.
That team had a very good defense, a strong running game, and two studs at receiver.
I was 12, but even then I knew he was one of two really bad options that held that team back.
I think you are forgetting just how bad Malone was. lol
They essentially traded Pickens and a 2 for Metcalf and a 3, a terrible deal that made the team weaker. Metcalf was a huge disappointment. He...
Are you going to write something about Gainwell on a thread about Gainwell?
Yes, I'm aware that you are trying to find a way to phrase things that removes many of the defense's worst performances, the ones they cost the...
Normally, he brings thoughtful analysis to these discussions, but there was no good reason to drag Pickett into a thread about Gainwell.
Not nothing, but the offense still did its job in both of those games. The defense couldn't hold up.
Sorry, but no, that logic does not hold up at all. Whatever happened in the victories doesn't erase the games the defense lost for them. The...
Granted, but that alone doesn't explain the huge gap between what Pickens did and what Metcalf did last season. Any dispute of what the Steelers...
Pickens was already a very good player with the potential to be an All-Pro. He turned that potential into production in 2025. That is undeniable.
I'm sure everyone is fully convinced by your classy, well-developed, and thoughtful argument.
The opener was a clear example of the offense carrying the Steelers and winning despite the defense. They gave up 394 yards and 32 points to the...
Why drag him into this thread? There is no reason to do it other than to start a problem. I am specifically talking about what is happening on...
I am addressing Blast's statement. I did not bring Pickett into a thread about Gainwell. Doing so was clearly trolling.
That tells you just how bad a move it was by the Steelers because they managed to get fleeced by the Cowboys.
