You're right. I missed OTs in the plot. For reference, MM drafted 6 and Tomlin drafted 5 in the first three rounds. So not much difference there....
Disagree BB was a good GM. He couldn't draft a WR worth a spit (Brady is probably still cursing him). And his drafts in the last five years were...
They churned because they missed too much. And that rep isn't deserved when looking at MM vs the Steelers. Too many misses. AB saved their bacon.
I agree. But then you get tangled up in 'what is success?' If you are a believer in PFR's AV values here's an example breakdown for DBs in the...
Do we need to fact check this? The change in offense happened with Arians departure and Haley's arrival. And it was necessary because BA would...
A follow up plot showing Tomlin vs McCarthy drafts for the first three rounds. [note; since they both had the same number of picks (60) the...
LOL. They drafted a 1st round QB in a weak QB class and wasted 2 years on him. This QB class is equally weak. Playing a 6th round QB or a backup...
Welp that business decision by his agent work out great for his career. What's he on now? His third team? :rolleyes: By the time his career is...
Porter's most important job is shutting down the other team's WR1, especially against AFCN opponents. I don't have his stats vs who he was...
Breakdown on % of picks for each position. A very interesting contrast between the two. Some might argue 'yea but' on specific positions but over...
Dunno. How many seasons did McCarthy have Rodgers sit behind Favre before playing him? That seems to have worked out just fine. And which FA QB...
Good points here. Tomlin's approach of 'slowing the game down' just caused them more problems when they got behind with teams that had actual...
MM's grade should be based on visible progress. That is something we didn't see with Tomlin's last half decade (or more). And since MM is some...
[IMG]
He drops more than he catches.
The debate is whether JPJ is in fact a high end CB. SIS had him ranked 67th in the NFL. He was 12th best in yds/tgt and 6th best in comp % allowed...
Steelers took their chance on your QB draft pick Pickett but after two seasons he hightailed it out of the 'Burgh. He wasn't the answer....
Honestly don't recall details on the ratings but it seems obvious it is cumulative across games played.
Are you forgetting that Brady started 4 years before Roethlisberger? Then add in all the extra post season games for NWE.
Yea, that would be interesting. I don't have that info and I'm not sure where to even find it.
