Give up what? The question was name a coach that had done a better job with a franchise QB. I never laid out any parameters. THE OP HAD ALREADY...
What argument was lost???
Refer to my last post to you in the Tomlin thread. I don't feel like repeating myself.
Cowher only coached three more years because he didn't want to coach anymore after those three years. There's no indication that Tomlin is getting...
Well...I wont complain for sure if he ultimately becomes a world beater. I dont care how they get it done, or who with, as long as they get it...
So you really believe in a guy who couldnt beat out Duck Hodges for a starting position??? Consistently at least...
I honestly dont know why anymore people get so caught up in playoff wins. I'd be curious to know how many of those teams over that time went on to...
That...plus it's clear as day upper management and coaches have no faith in Rudolph. I mean its blatantly obvious or Roethlisberger would be...
If at the end of the day all anybody cares about at the end of the day is the Lombardi trophy then everything you just said is for shhhhh and I...
1) Claim is wrong in what way? If we're talking about the ultimate prize which is SB appearances/ wins which is what has so many people up in arms...
I thought we were talking since Tomlin became coach or at least since Brady's run started?? but since you want to up the ante by going into the...
you mean because they are Offensive coaches??? Tomlin came up on the Defensive side of coaching so your point makes no sense here and what do you...
I would honestly take all four of your examples over Rudolph and I don't know who wouldn't. i would be curious to know who would.
I really don't get the point of you pointing out any of the four things above. Either you've misunderstood my point or you're trying to force...
yeah, but you initially picked/used the last 10 years not the first 10.
My bad. I apologize....thats on me.
Actually I didnt change the rule...Manning had three different coaches during that time frame....so really its no comparison one way or another....
It's not changing the rules...I'm stating facts. The focus is still the coach and his franchise QB. Tell me who would deny the point I made?? If...
Maybe you should also mention Manning is one level above Roethlisberger in QB talent and Brady is two levels.
Why do people do that on here?? Reminds me of that one ridiculous thread with the imposter. Its cleay an attempt to minimize his successes.
