Howard or Rudolph?

This should have been in the green font. Sometimes, not all functions work on my iphone.

Howard or Rudolph? To me this should not even be a thought for this team moving forward.

I have no ill feelings toward Mason Rudolph. Rudolph has shown he can be a serviceable backup. But, that is all he can be. It also seems to be all he aspires to be. We do not need that on this team at this time. Will Howard is focused on trying to become the next franchise QB for the Steelers. Players with that mindset should be the focus for the team right now. I have no problem with letting Howard learn for another season behind a proven leader like Rodgers. The team builds nothing significant by keeping a 30yr old career backup in the mix of starter conversations. If we did not have Will Howard and Drew Allar in the QB room, I'd be all for letting Rudolph continue his career here as Arod's backup. But we do have 2 guys that want to be more than career backups.

 

the two young guys still have time to be more than backups. rodgers and mason will be gone next year. rodgers for sure. masons contract runs out at the end of this season. we or they will know enough about the two youngsters by that time. neither one may be the guy. everybody wants to base the future on a 3rd and 6th round pick but they may draft another next year in the first or second and make it all mute.

 

I think they will end up carrying 4. I could be totally wrong lol.

 

Haven't we seen enough check down football under AR last year? Surely the new coaching staff will install downfield offensive football that ALL Qb's could run.

 

all depends on how much time the O-line gives whomever is the QB. we shouldn't want any of our QB's to be getting hit often so if they have to check down then they will. i don't think mccarthy's offense will be built on that though.

 

It's difficult for me to understand the thinking behind fans wanting to get rid of Rodgers, who is proven to be a top tier QB in this league, in mind and ability whatever he has lost to age. But those same fans seem to want to keep a middling career backup on the 53 just in case? OR get rid of the proven guy to see what the career middling backup has in a starter role just one more time?


Would you rather your new QBs learn behind Aaron Rodgers or Mason Rudolph? Because one of those is the reality, whatever else a fan would rather see happen. Aaron Rodgers is clearly the better choice by far.


Reality vs Hypothetical should be the thread title.

 

Clickbait nothing more

Not a single quote from a single coach

Just Dulac

 

Top tier QB

 

Well that’s a definite maybe

 

I think part of the goal on offense will be to not have the old QB get killed.

And since it sounds like we'll only have 1 OL from last year coming back to play the same position, my guess is that protection will be an issue at the beginning of the season (at least).

We'll see.

 

It is OTA

They will try all kinds of combinations

Don’t read too much into anything

 

SB champ. SB MVP. 4 time league MVP. 5 time first team all-pro. All decade team for 2010's. 10 time Pro Bowl selection. 6 times league best TD to INT ratio.

There's more. So yes, I think he has proven himself to be a top tier NFL QB.

 

Ok

I’m going to go put my dunce hat on

I thought from the thread title you were talking about Rudolph

Small print disclaimer I’m on meds until I get surgery