Who would have led the Steelers to the most wins so far if he played every snap at QB....

Ben

Clearly....

we would have 1 or 2 losses.

UGLY wins, but wins, all else equal

BUFF still would have won big.

 

What kind of dumb ass question is this??.. Everyone knows the anser is Ben

 

Ben. No doubt in my mind. I think we are probably 5-2 with Ben.

 

Easily Big Ben would be better than all the others at this point in the season. It doesn't matter if it was 2004, 2022 or every season in between. He would have simply tossed Canada's playbook in the trash and made several fourth qtr comebacks. MT's non losing season streak would be safe yet again. What you see now is a coaching dumpster fire with no one to bail them out.

 

Dan Marino

 

Not even a contest, it would be Ben. He was what kept the Steelers in games despite the horrible O line, and we'd have at least 2 more wins right now with Ben behind center.

 

I think Ben finished his career tied with Drew Brees for the most come from behind 4th quarter victories in NFL history. I agree with everyone else the Steelers would be 5-2 or at worse 4-3 with Ben at QB.

 

John Elway

 

Ben, only because he had the luxury to tell Canada to eff and make playground plays as the game flowed.

 

This is one of your dumber posts

You need to stop letting that pos clown tickle your tonsils

 

I was ready to move on from Ben and was bamboozled into thinking a diff QB would run Canada's offense better. If the games played out the exact same we'd def be at worst 4-3 with Ben. I still would not think we'd have a shot in the playoffs, but we'd prob end up better than .500.

 

This x 1,000. Steelers would be 3-4 with Ben instead of 2-5.

 

How about we play a different "what if" game? What would our record be if we had receivers who could catch consistently? DBs that could do the same? Without those, I doubt Marino could get us to a better record than we have now!

 

I wonder if we'd have been better off with Mason??????? Not counting Ben since he is not a Steeler anymore.

 

Yeah I'm sure with a worse offensive line, and No Pickens His 7 TDs, and 4 ints wouldn't have helped compared to the 5 td , and 7 ints our combined Qbs have thrown in 7 games.
Although all of this is a moot point....because Ben is retired.....,and right now our future is Pickett.