You can only keep one Dwyer or Mendenhall, who is it?

I've been so impressed with Dwyer I do believe he is more the type of back we need. He can be a game changer/clock killer. I felt he was benched too early a few weeks back after a fumble. What are your thoughts.

 

I'll get back with you at the end of the season.

 

Yea, I'll see what Mendy does when he is healthy first

 

I really like Dwyer though. I said in a post before the season that Dwyer would be the starter by mid-season, regardless of Mendy's health. We shall see.

 

Neither lets get stephen jackson

 

Dwyer.

 

Well regardless of what happens it looks like Isaac Redman will be the odd man out come end of the season.

 

I will say this...its a good "problem" to have. I like both Mendy and Dwyer myself...nothing against Redman or anything.

 

dwyer

 

Mendy

 

Dwyer

 

Dwyer definitely

 

I think Dwyer is becoming a fan fave but I think Mendy is a Tomlin fave and that's gonna make the difference. I don't think we're gonna get rid of Mendy for Dwyer but I personally like Dwyer better though. I wanna see Mendy come back and play consistently in Haley's offense and then we'll know for sure.

 

Why pick one? This is the first time in a long time we not only have 1, not 2 but 3 good RBs. Get them all healthy, get Adams on the line or not looked good today, keep the passing game strong...

But if I have to pick...Dwyer. I just like the straight forward bulldozer type RB.

 

depends on the price dwyer is rfa while mendy is ufa , both are good , redman too and he is rfa

 

i think redman is done as a steeler

 

Dwyer!! I LOVE his running style

 

Bradshaw wants Jonathan "Dyer". Did anyone else hear him call him that?

 

I did. LOL. They were trying to tell him it's "dwyer" and he just kept talking. I thought it was funny too.

 

I have to agree!

 

I graduated high school with Jon Dwyer at Kell High School near Atlanta Ga. I am really impressed so far. It will be interesting to see how he does against the defenses like Baltimore and the Giants. I think its to early to tell whether to keep both or just Dwyer. Time will tell.

 

No, the point is we're dealing w/ two, count em, two NFL starting caliber RBs.

Been posting this a long time, against the wave so to speak, but Redman an NFL starter he is not. He's a keeper in the sense that he's that one of guy that can come in for that extremely hard 3 yrds and get it. Just don't follow it up with another run after that cuz he's exhausted. Not a starter but a one off guy.

Mendy is elite, use him in tandem w/ a real power back like Dwyer and you'll see both rise to new heights.

They're all keepers