Who would you pick: John Elway or Peyton Manning?

I used to think that Manning was an above average Q.B. until a game the Colts played against, I think, the Bucs. Cots were so far behind towards the end of the game, I turned it off. Figuring there was no way they could come back. Found out the next day that they came back and won. I watched the replay and my opinion of Manning changed forever.

 

Weird seems like Peyton has become more likable over time but John Elway the other way around.

 

Elway. Peyton is one of the greatest...but his second ring was a retirement gift.

 

Agree, Manning was way smarter than Elway.

Of course Elway's arm was 10 times better than Manning's.

If they are both rookies I take Elway #1, because you can't coach Elway's God given arm.

 

Nobody told you that. That's what happens when you only read the 1st sentence. LoL.
They matter, winning regular seasons matter, playoffs matter, but SBs matter the most....I repeat the most,and I believe Elway went to 5.

 

Only one of them went to UT so that's an easy choice. Although they both have horse faces.