Who is the greatest QB in Steelers history?

Come on Man...I Love ...Love Bradshaw (the man outside of Blount who made Me love football)....but people exaggerate.....Bradshaw was 9- 14 for 96 yards ,and a TD in His 1st SB ...WOW That was amazing.....No way the Steelers could have Won with out all that...LoL....So he had exactly the same amount of TDs Ben had in His 1st SB ....one TD.
Also in Bradshaws last SB he has 2 tds, and 3 ints....some people on Here would have raked Ben over the coals for that.
Also that lowest ranking in SB history for a winner has 2 be fixed.
Payton Manning had 2 turnover,and No TDs with a win....How is that not lower than somebody that actually scored????

 

Bradshaw’s first Super Bowl was won by the defense and Franco Harris, I’ll give you that. Bradshaw ran the offense very efficiently and had a TD pass and didn’t have any major blunders. But he was a ton better in that game than Ben was in his first Super Bowl. The Steelers best quarterback that day was Antwaan Randle El! And the other three Super Bowls Terry played in…the Steelers would absolutely not have won those games had Bradshaw not been the quarterback of the Steelers…PERIOD. Stat line and interceptions aside, he made throws in those games that only somebody with his kind of freakish arm talent could have made. Roger Staubach couldn’t make those throw. Fran Tarkenton couldn’t make those throws, Kenny Stabler couldn’t make those throws, and for gosh sakes, Vince Ferragamo couldn’t make those throws! I don’t care what Bradshaw’s stats say, he made some phenomenal throws in those three Super Bowls when he had to make them. He didn’t freeze up, he didn’t panic, he didn’t choke! We’re all entitled to our opinions and mine is and will always be that Terry Bradshaw is the greatest Steelers quarterback ever! And at this point it seems that the cross section of Steeler nation represented on this board agrees with me.

 

Randle El was definitely vice-MVP of Super Bowl XL...along with Ike Taylor with the INT.

Ward, Randle El and Taylor. All heroes.

Edit:. Willie Parker and Alan Faneca.... honorable mentions.

 

Oh great googlie mooglie you are twisting the facts to promote your Ben boy

Bradshaws QB rating was 108.0

Bens QB rating was 22.6

Bradshaw did what was needed while his running back set a super bowl rushing record

Ben sucked

 

Both scored a one whole Touchdown, and 9 freaking completions. Both of them.....So Yet somehow one was awesome, and the other wasn't.
Difference was one was in His 4th year,and the other was in His 2nd.
Your nostalgic imagination is clouding Your judgement.
I Loved both of them.

 

Funny. TB12...You say... stat line,and ints aside....Yet Ben...you make sure the stats are told. LoL.
You honestly don't see the hypocritical statement in this???
I mean that's what You said.

 

The only stat line I regularly quote with regard to Ben is his sucky performance in his first Super Bowl.

Look, I love Ben…he was a GREAT quarterback, the 2nd best in Steelers history. We are fortunate as Steeler fans to have had two all-time greats at the position. The thing that separates Bradshaw from Ben is the ice in his veins in the biggest moments. But I respect your loyalty to Ben and your opionion that he’s the best, even though I disagree.

 

I'm not more Loyal honestly 2 one more than the other. I've watched both play, and Loved both. I have jerseys By both.
If one gets put down....I stick up for the other.
I just try not 2 let What actually happened 2 interfere with My emotions , or Vice Versa.
No hard feelings

 

Blah blah

Ben sucked in the SB vs Seattle

Bradshaw didn’t

There ain’t not none no way around that

 

Whatever.
What part of both had exactly the same amount of completions, and TDs in their 1st SB don't You understand.
So....

 

Woohoo
I love it when fans argue a championship for their team
Cue the Roxette song

 

One played well

One didn’t

Isn’t that the point

 

Man I really want a middle finger button.

 

That’s ok

I know I’m number one in your heart

 

I get that a lot

Mostly from my good friends

 

There’s two legitimate answer to this question. Terry Bradshaw or Ben Roethlisberger. No one else is in the conversation

 

So?

 

I answered in the pole. Bradshaw.
Completely ridiculous to put Neil O’Donnell as an option.

 

I put NOD as an option almost tongue in cheek after Mashburn argued with me that he was a better quarterback than Bradshaw.

 

and

AGAINST THE RULES
OF
EVER SAYING THE NAME OF QB TO NOT EVER BE SAID OF EVER AGAIN

NOD YES

 

I’m calling it now…according to the most knowledgeable Steeler fans in the world (who happen to frequent this board)…

TERRY BRADSHAW IS THE GREATEST STEELERS QUARTERBACK OF ALL-TIME garnering 54% of the vote to Big Ben’s 43%.

Your honor, I rest my case. Thanks for participating!

 

Bubby brister.

 

The dude had the tools to be a great quarterback. He just didn’t have it between the ears.

 

Who the best wr in steelers history?