The fourth down and goal call....

typical simple reply

we LOSE always in January, coaching and decisions MATTER

 

dummy coaching, that is why. (MT and AS)

NO IDEA what he wanted to do their - you saw that AROD was agitated and dumbfounded by it all

MT is so NOT USED to playing with a lead that he had NO IDEA how to keep it

thank GOD Wilson can run 22 mph or we'd be sitting here 2-2........with a colossal choke discussion!

 

MT and AS have NO IDEA, that is for sure

 

can can't tell some dull fans about situational play calling.

 

nope - we won and he will be political, keeping his mouth shut

we don't have to be!

 

At the end of the day we don't know that conversation. MT could have been on the fence about what he wanted to do. Leaning toward the 3 but already had a short one blocked, so considering going for it and pinning them at their GL worst case. Spoke with his players and made the decision based on how they felt about it. That's not 'caving in'. That's situational football. Yes, I thought the smart play was to kick there as well. But the decision wasn't based at all on how I felt or on what I thought. If they make the TD it's a gutsy call. If they settle for the 3 OR go for it and don't make it, it's gonna get second guessed. I don't believe any of them ever wondered what we would think about which decision they made though.


What was our alignment? What was the defensive alignment? We know that close they were playing man. Did we have a strong side or did we line up balanced? I wish you guys talked more about football and less about how you feel after games, that's more the point of my previous post.
What did the Vikings take away? What were we able to exploit offensively? Did they adjust to anything? In what way?

Lots of discussion out there to get into. We're on our bye week. 2 weeks of 'what I would have done' is going to be pretty boring. That's my opinion. That's my feelings on it. That's what I'm second guessing on.

 

If it's true that ARod talked MT out of kicking and into going for it....i would guess it's every bit as likely ARod called the play after seeing the defense line up. But, I don't know for sure.

 

Ravens, Bilsls and Detroit lose always in January , and very early Feb, I guess you are correct coaching matters.

 

Kinda what I was thinking, but unlike most on here, I don't know what was really said. I just know he changed Tomlin's mind.

 

But that four yards per carry average wasn't in the shadow of the goal post.

That's what is faulty about analytics. You can say you should go for it on 4th down and two, but that doesn't take into account that the other team might have two pro bowlers on their defensive line against the best rush defense in the NFL or two 320-lb. All-Americans on college football's best defensive line or your offensive line just isn't that great in run blocking. It's an all encompassing analytic stat that doesn't take into account actual specifics at that moment.

 

It was still a two-score game with the field goal. It would have just made it a two-touchdown game. I just don't understand running the ball on that play.

 

Equally frustrating was the decision to punt on 4th and a foot late in the game. We gained 2 yards on a tush push that everyone in the stadium knew was coming. Yet we chickened out on 4th and one foot

 

We won despite Tomlin not because of him.

 

An incomplete pass pins them deep, too. The only way the run works is if it gets them in the end zone, but the chances of that play getting them a score were very low.

 

Ya... that's where the risk of INT on the pass vs a run up the middle comes in. I personally would be going with the lowest risk.

Having said that, the Bus did fumble against Indy in 2005.

 

A pass would have been an even bigger boneheaded play

 

Visions of Russell Wilson Super Bowl XLIX?

 

Tomlin at his best
Yet some will still say he is a genius
Tomlin couldn’t develop a roll of film
Let alone a player
Can’t manage game clock
Could go on and on and on
Had an outstanding roster and done nothing with it Brown Ben Bell
Some numnuts blame it all on Ben?
Yet the defense gives up 45 pts to Jags
Ben threw an int or two
Like talking to a wall
I Love the Steelers not Tomlin
Edit: spelled numb-nuts wrong
Guess I am a numb nut

 

You of all people would’ve took the 3 in that situation.
You are agreeing they should’ve took the 3 correct?
Im Dave
I get confused

 

I thought so

 

Yes IMO . Tomlin should have stuck with his guns when Rodgers talked him out of it, and kicked the 3.

 

Agreed
Not so sure I would blame Arod and not Tomlin
Once again I love the Steelers in spite of Tomlin