Superbowl with Leftwich and then Ben is healthy, who starts?

I must still be half asleep this morning. I thought I read a thread asking who would start in the SB between Lefty and Ben. Naw... Couldnt be... I must still be asleep and dreaming...

No way does this team win a SB (or even get to the SB) without Ben.

 

I agree, but to compare that advantage vs. Lefty and vs. Rogers is comparing apples to oranges.

 

this thread is pure fantasy , basically he sayd that if lefty become a peyton manning would he start him over a rusty ben ?

 

I agree, it would be stupid to put the much poorer performing QB in for the SB after he comes off an injury.

 

Not even apples and oranges. More like comparing apples and bananas. Or better yet, like comparing apples and an old tire...

 

If we are living in fantasy land and the scenario that the OP stated was true then we'd be foolish to not stick with Lefty. But I honestly can't see any scenario where Lefty is THAT good. I think he'll be ok for a few games until Ben comes back, but I don't see him playing lights out with a perfect passer rating.

In the real world my pick has to be Ben.

 

I think that is everyone's answer in the real world.