~OFFICIAL 2025 TSF.COM FANTASY DRAFT STEELERS VOTING & DISCUSSION~

Fair point (though the reports I've read put his drops at 10%), but given his history (QB in HS, didn't see more than 30 targets until 2023) and usage I'm taking that number with a grain of salt.

 

My vote is for DJ Giddens.

 

I'm not crazy about any of these options. I definitely don't want a quarterback. I want Savion Williams even less. There are far better receiving options still available.

If these are the options, I vote for Giddens. The pick fills a need and he would make more of an immediate impact than William's or Howard would.

 

I will also vote Giddens.

 

At least Tuten will contribute as a RB and KR this year. Howard will be an inactive 3rd team QB standing on the sidelines in street clothes all season.

 

Not sure who'd they be outside of maybe Jaylin Noel, who's basically this year's Roman Wilson.

Williams is a boom/bust prospect, but as is adds a dynamic layer to an offense that needs a boost in that arena, with the upside of developing into a formidable every-down receiver.

 

How do you know this?

 

I woke up this morning to see Seattle has taken my 3rd round QB in Qwen Ewers.

I guess that swings my vote to QB Will Howard.

With the QB room of Mason and Skylar, you have to take a QB that can compete for the Starting job immediately.

 

We'll find out more in a couple of weeks about how teams feel about Howard. If some team takes him in the second round then they have plans for him to eventually be a starter. If he falls to the 4th or later then they are looking at him as a backup to fill out the QB room.

 

You do understand this is a fan fantasy draft and only on this forum, right?

 

Tuten might contribute in some way, true. Warren and Gainwell are already kick returners. Patterson is a kick returner. Are you certain we need another? We already know that each time he fumbles it will be his last carry of the game because he will get sat down. We have witnessed this before. But he is fast.

 

Patterson was the worst KR in the league last year. Warren was only back there because Patterson was so bad at it. You are right about if Tuten fumbles in his first game then you wouldn't see him again for a very long time.

 

What?! Oh man you just burst my bubble I thought that Khan was reading this board and was writing in stone every pick we made.

 

Nope. Which is why the impassioned speech seemed out of place to me.


My original comment on Tuten's fumble issues was just that. A comment on his fumble issues. I don't see the need to expand and explain on my vote. I honestly don't care if it wins or not. I think I voted for aDB at 21 and a DL won.
Next pick is 123. I'm going punter. We need a third string punter.

 

Sorry I guess I got carried away. You or nobody else has to explain your pick to me it's your opinion and it is just as good as mine if not better.

 

Don't know that I would've called it an impassioned speech, but if it was, so what? I get passionate about this team on here at times, just keep it respectful.

Your comment on Tuten was snarkish. If you're going to dish it out, be prepared to take it.

 

I'll tie things back up.

I vote for DJ Giddens RB Kansas St

Giddens is a good complement to Jaylen Warren, who I don't believe can be an every down #1 RB.

The Steelers also have Giddens scheduled for one of the 30 allowed pre-draft visits, so there is interest on our part.

 

They also hosted Shedeur Sanders and we all know he not sliding that far

 

Now that is funny.