Discussion in 'Steelers Talk' started by Steelersfan43, Jan 17, 2023.
How much better is Tomlin over McCarthy?
If McCarthy takes Dallas and wins a ring I would consider him better than Tomlin. No I don’t want that to happen lol
More phillipponi babble bull****
If it was someone else I would have gave it done thought
When he come on the radio I turn it off
I certainly don’t follow him on twatter
quick...stir that pot to get attention from people. Is Fillipponi a member of this board?
Based on some of the foolishness posted here either he’s a board member or there are board members who listen to him and can’t think for themselves
Dallas beat a poor Tampa team and that's that.
Things get harder now.
And don't forget Prescott has 3 straight games throwing ridiculous pick 6's.
But McCarthy has managed the team well, despite ownership.
They have provided him some weapons and he has a good OC.
So where does that put him on the evolutionary poll?
He did a crap job keeping the Packers "fresh"
He does have a Super Bowl ring
I guess he could climb a few rungs should he get another.
The last thing I want to see is either the cryboys or Rice a Roni winning another Lombardi especially the cryboys and that dolt Jones.
I do feel that Rice a Roni will beat the cryboys. Then it's up to the eagles although Rice a Roni is a powerhouse.
It's not just about playoff wins. He's had 4 years with a losing season. And he's been on two teams.
When green bay had him kick rocks, lafeur took them to 3 consecutive seasons with being first in the division. With one year losing in the division, the other two the conference.
So unless he wins a ring this year, he won't be regarded as on the fans respect level as Tomlin.
Hasn't he had Brett Favre, Aaron Rodgers, and Dak Prescott as qb's? A Hall of Famer, a 4 time Player of the Year, and, well, Dak. Playing most of his time in the NFC North, with Detroit and Chicago? And, up to this year, the NFC East, with the Giants and the WTF?
And people say Tomlin underperformed with Ben.
We know for a fact there are a bunch of people here that can’t think for themselves. #pollywantacracker
You could say he’s had two hof quarterbacks
Again they just beat a team with a worse record than us.....That We beat with a Rookie Qb playing His 2nd, or 3rd game ever, Trubisky, and without TJ Watt. Please!!!!!
Congratulations Dallas, and The bullfrog Mike McCarthy on such an awesomely amazing win. LoL
Well, would we rather have a coach with 1 SB win and 11 playoff wins who’s team in the playoffs as of today and will play this weekend, or…
have a coach with 1 SB win and 9 playoff wins who’s team is at home contemplating keeping Canada as OC and edmunds as safety?
I like it when we don’t compare ourselves to an inferior organization.
I totally agree with that! I can’t stand Jerry jones.
but somehow, his coach has better metrics than rooney’s coach, even though Rooney is theoretically the much better owner.
Could it have anything to do with two hall of fame quarterbacks? No. Nevermind. That’s just crazy talk
Geezer Favre + Young Rodgers == Geezer Ben + Young Ben
Hmmm..a couple of posters come to mind..though they have been accused as being just one...so the possibility is certainly there. BTW I am the only one with a direct contact to Art. not the Art...but the Art Art let a fart and blew it all apart...our relationship stinks.
thanks for not keeping your relationship silent and potentially deadly
I thought you said you liked intelligent conversation?
and yet he's on this board...
I don’t know. I think there are a number of people that are interested in talking about football. Unfortunately every single thread gets turned into tomlin sucks, Canada sucks, we suck, fire this guy, fire that guy yada yada yada
Both are good but not great coaches. A lot goes into the equation- ownership, assistant coaches (we are cheap) , personnel decisions ... I would say about even.
Pretty sure Tomlin had a HOF QB his entire career as well. Minus this season, which far exceeded expectations thanks in part to a very weak NFC south otherwise we are sub .500 without a doubt.