Do you think mason should be our #1?

Seems that way. I would've liked to have seen how Pickett would've operated with a competent OC, but the physical tools and traits he has shown thus far say solid backup to me.

And good for the Packers (and Willis) if they forge a good union there. Willis was the epitome of a high ceiling/low floor QB prospect. If they can bring his floor to capable backup that's more than he was a couple of years ago.

 

I voted no to Mason starting

But since right now it’s Mason vs Skylar I’m picking Mason

 

Steelers motto with regard to QBs seems to be:

Give us your old QB.
Give us your tired QB.
Give us your benched QB.
Validating other teams' decisions one QB at a time since 2019.

 

A wise man knows when to hedge his bets!!!

 

Mason sounds like a guy who can swing a hammer and fight. Skylar sounds like someone who is going home with a bloody nose and tears. So I have to go with Mason. Yep, I know. I am being an internet bully.....but come on, the guys name is Skylar.......

 

Why would they panic? They might not win a playoff game if they're forced to start Mason? Not winning a playoff game is so out of character that the fans might revolt due to success withdraw? What would we do?! OMG! I'm sure Tomlin's comfortable, he's got nothing to worry about.

The sentiment I'm getting from most people is that "Hey, who knows?", and aren't going to sweat a bad season, as it may break the stranglehold of mediocrity.

 

I voted no but I think he will be. Slim Pickens at this point and he is familiar with the offense. I don’t care for Russell Wilson returning and Rodger’s won’t be the answer either. I predict 5-12 if he doesn’t start and 8-9 if he does. Nothing to get excited about going into next season. Just as I predicted 3 years ago for the Pens. It’s going to be a rough ride for a few seasons.

 

Im a little disappointed it's a two-year contract. Steelers should give him three starter years. At a minimum.