FWIW, I think you are using the term "cherry picking" incorrectly. Looking at the entire careers of both players and realizing that one of them...
Great call. Ward is the only jersey I own. But Troy is my favorite Steeler of all time.
What do you mean when you say dominant? I don't think either of these guys were dominant QBs. Although Ben had a multiple season stretch where he...
I'd imagine that the overlap of people who really like Kenny and people who are fans of Pitt is pretty close to 100%.
But he doesn't seem to have gotten hurt!
I do think Mason got the short end of the stick a lot. But he did get a chance to be a starter when he left. He did not succeed in that role.
Because their 3rd string QB played at least as well as he did. Same as a 3rd string QB in every NFL organization Kenny has ever played for. When...
Contract value is set by the CBA. Amount of guaranteed money isn't (at least that's my understanding). The link you have here appears to be the...
I think it's about the order they got drafted in. QB's are "special". They can't get more money because the money is determined by the CBA. So I...
On the previous board I came from, I would usually say that I thought Payton was the best "current" comp to Tomlin (this was pre Brees retirement...
It normally would. But contracts can "toll" if a player doesn't ever play in the last year of their contract due to injury. "Tolling" means that...
If his contract tolls, it makes sense to at least bring him to camp. First thing to see is whether or not he starts camp on the PUP. I believe...
Well played Joel.
I don't get this either. His argument in the post you're quoting is basically: Results are how you judge who is better. His conclusion is: The...
Aside from all of this, I really thought Brees did good stuff off the field re: hurricane Katrina. And thinking that he isn't as good as Ben...
As always QBs are much more important than HCs. Even for very good HCs. Especially for mediocre HCs like Whiz.
We agree on the bold part. But you seem to be arguing that this made Brees more "dominant". Really it made him more "consistent"...which he...
FWIW, contrary to popular belief I think it's OK to admit when you're wrong on the internet. I just did it twice on the site because Steelers43...
Thanks! I thought we were down by 4. If I thought it through, I would have seen that didn't make sense becuase the Cardinals needed a TD to win...
So you don't think they would have been able to play 3rd down if Holmes doesn't make that catch? Even in the CFL, you get 3rd down. :drinks:
