So much for the idea that you didn't start this thread for the purpose of more Tomlin bashing. I write this as somebody who has been calling for...
I agree that they were setting things up to remove Butler, but that was before the defense showed great improvement this season. I hope you are...
Are you hoping for transparency, clarity and consistency from the NFL on such matters? You will likely be disappointed.
Chris Simms would know all about throwing egregious interceptions. Rudolph should have been pulled at halftime Thursday. Then you go back to him...
Dobbs regressed in that third preseason while Rudolph improved significantly in his second. Much of this is subjective. The only factual error...
They sat him for six games and possibly a few more. That's a message.
This season has shown they can't trust Conner. He is far too brittle. Samuels has also shown that he is not a long-term answer. The Steelers are...
The fair comparison is preseason, in which Rudolph outplayed Dobbs by a significant margin and took the No. 2 job from him. There is no evidence...
How dare you bring facts into this discussion!:drinks:
Neither was Dobbs, who sucked the one time he was called upon for more than a single play last season and then lost the No. 2 job to Rudolph....
You claimed that I have a disease. You said I wasn't worth debating with. You made a comment about what gives me a woody. You falsely claimed that...
Please note that I'm not the one making this personal. You are. I'm discussing the topic while you are taking shots at me. There is nothing...
There is no spin to it. You compared the accuracy of the two quarterbacks. You claimed that Dobbs wasn't as inaccurate as Rudolph. During this...
Please tell me what I misrepresented in your post. The simple truth is I did no such thing. If you wish to drop out of the discussion at this...
Here is the part where you compared the accuracy of Rudolph and Dobbs. The only way you could possibly make this claim is to compare preseason...
Before we spiral into foolishness again, here is the post I quoted. The first statement does not fit the facts. It suggests that Rudolph didn't...
They agreed to the trade, so they must have thought it was worth taking. The evidence is on my side there. You absolutely compared the two. You...
Injuries have played a big part in this. One issue is the losses of Conner and Snell, the two best short-yardage options on this team. Who is...
He also didn't face starters in real games the way Rudolph has this season. We saw that once from Dobbs last season and he was terrible against...
Rudolph beat out Dobbs in the preseason. It was clear and easy to see in the preseason games. Dobbs was still as erratic as ever, mixing in the...
