You're using information from beyond Edmund's 5th season and comparing it to Najee's first 5 years. We don't know what will happen with Najee in...
What do you think the word subjective means? Note: the antonym is objective (the adjective, not the noun). If succ% is subjective, how is it that...
The UFA market showed that real-life NFL teams valued Najee more than Edmunds. But not by much.
I'll give Kenny the benefit of the doubt. He doesn't have much else at this point IMO. Either way, it was a great catch by Najee.
If you want to argue that neither are starting RBs but you'd prefer Najee if contracts were the same (money and structure), I don't think that's...
Remember that Najee's only in year 5. And he's been on more teams than Edmonds' was at this point in his career. Although that's only because no...
They aren't good ones anyway. And I did answer your questions. Even though I think you're not asking them in good faith. I don't think you...
Good to know the context. I didn't mind Edmunds. He was consistent and available. Certainly not a world beater. But decent as the...
I get this. I think it's a disappointment that he didn't earn a 2nd contract. But I think it's about what you'd expect from a late first round RB....
He was better. But I wouldn't say much better. After he left Edmunds could only get a vet minimum contract. Najee got a little more than that. So...
Sure. And neither of them (Najee or Warren) can perform that role to the level of an average to above-average RB. This is why Najee lost his...
I wouldn't call Najee a failed 1st round pick. But he was certainly a disappointment relative to where he was drafted. He's the RB version of a...
Yep. But I think it's a really bad sign that he can't get on the field. Hope it's not another failed offensive pick. We've had a run of them lately.
Why do you think success rate is subjective? Because it's the opposite of that. [IMG]
Yep. Which is far from great. But also not the same thing as never winning anything with Ben. I think there are many issues Tomlin has. And I...
Felt, you are having issues with logic here. You keep trying to ask these "gotcha" questions. This is how it must feel like to get interviewed by...
I don't want Lazard except maybe on the practice squad. If the Rats want to burn a roster spot on him, that's fine with me. We don't need...
And they didn't have to fully guarantee the salary 2 years out. That's a huge thing for this team. They hate guaranteeing money past the season...
This was always my issue with Najee. People talk about his yards. But it's only because he got a lot of carries (and still never had a 38 yard...
FWIW, this also uses hindsight to know that in this alternate universe where we give him the option, Harris wouldn't have blown out his Achilles...
