All depends on Mason, Baker, and Lamar. Who's for real and who's a fraud? We already know Andy is mediocre. At best.
Given the franchise's circumstances the Bush trade was way better imo. The Ben injury changes everything, unfortunately. It's a QB driven game....
What? Are you saying that even if Rudolph craps the bed this year that drafting a potential successor to Ben would not be a priority? They've...
You don't seem to understand how this works. If you identify a potential risk (no good QB successor to Ben in this case) and deem that risk high...
27-17 niners 28 passes
Goodness. It's about risk vs reward. I honestly don't know why this is so hard to understand. If you think through the possible outcomes this...
No. My analysis is not the worst case scenario. It's looking at various scenarios and where the Steelers stand if those play out. I'm not even...
I'm comparing to the time of the draft. Do you really believe the Steelers are legit SB contenders this year? He'll have 3 years remaining...
Scenario A: Steelers play well and Rudolph plays well meaning they end up 9-7 or 10-6, in the playoffs, but don't make SB. Scenario B: Steelers...
He's definitely less cost controlled. 40% less,right? He'll have 3 years vs. 5 years for the draft pick. I certainly get that he's a more...
I didn't interpret what Bouchette wrote as the Steelers should intentionally tank, but rather that if Rudolph proves to be marginal that their...
I have to agree with shaner82 here. This is clearly a short-term gain move at the expense of the long-term. There are times that makes sense and...
Where they were drafted is not part of my argument. It really doesn't matter. My point is that if its the staff's fault that these players never...
I wrote it in the other tread but I'm not positive that this points to poor talent development as much as poor talent evaluation, meaning...
The Giants and the Jets are both going to be really bad. The Dolphins actually play both of them, the Jets twice of course, so I think 0-16 is...
Oh, he was definitely unhappy with how the Dolphins used him at safety. That was certainly part of it. I'll assume that Colbert had a talk with...
I'm going to be that guy that pumps the brakes. The NFL is full of QBs that looked legit for 8 games or even a full season only to fail the test...
What does this trade indicate: a) The Steelers are convinced that Ben will be back and healthy for 2020 and 2021 b) The Steelers are convinced...
If there were examples of players going somewhere else and thriving then I would agree, but that doesn't seem to be the case. They get drafted,...
That would make two positions worse. The 3rd string QB should, imo, be a guy that can develop into a capable backup at a minimum. He needs to be...
