I am going to seperate my responses out into 2 posts, one for offense and one for defense. On offense, I think your roster is very possible....
The 2-5-4 is basically a base 4/3 defense, but probably a little lighter in the shorts. Worilds and Jones end up being DEs with Timmons, Spence...
DEFENSE: Let's start here as I think it is much easier place to start because I think so much of the roster is already set. Dline - 6: Thomas,...
First, I truly believe that pick was never supposed to be more than Ben's backup. I have believed that all along. If he looked good enough to be...
I would like to see his play improve in the next 2 games before I say lock, but he would be on my roster right now over DHB.
I have always felt like pegging Landry as Ben's successor would make the expectations unreasonable. IMO, he was brought in to be a backup,...
My thoughts were Fuller followed by Gilbert, but Shazier honestly wasn't someone that I watched a lot. He has been nothing short of hugely...
I think the top 8 are givens.... Carter, H. Jones, and So'oto. So'oto has forced the TOs. H. Jones has recovered them. Carter hasn't shown...
I think we have 3 questions yet, with some clear leaders as well. 1. 6th Dlineman? 2. Last OLB LB? 3. Do they keep W. Allen or the rookie...
I see why they signed him, but at the moment I don't think he makes it. I would love to see them pull off a trade. Use him to get either another...
I will be looking as well. Roster building is probably the most important job of the coach and GM IMO. I love this stuff as well. I am down to...
When I started this, it was a LONG time ago. Guys who I never expected to step up have and guys like Embernasty aren't even around or have...
Earning it would be outplaying someone in the 2nd unit, guys like Hubbard and Browning and earning his spot. At the moment, he might make the...
My problem with keeping 9 Olineman is that they haven't really earned it. Hubbard and every other backup other than Wallace and Adams, including...
Poole (RB - do we keep a 5th?) Waters (TE - Paulson or Palmer could be kept instead. I think Blanchflower is a cut to the PS) Moye (WR - Do we...
While I agree in principle that we need 6 DL over another RB, I think Poole has done more to earn that spot at the moment than any of the...
OFFENSE: QB: Ben, Grad, Jones - I think Jones showed enough to at this point be considered for on the roster. It could change, but this is my...
My thoughts are as follows: 1. It was impossible to figure out what we had at backup QB as both guys were playing while running for their lives....
Like I said somewhere else, I'm not sure how you evaluate either of these QBs based on what you saw last night. Neither is a running QB and the...
I think it is important to remind ourselves that this is the Giants 2nd game and our first.
