You involved yourself in the mess, but feel free to ignore the evidence against your opinion if it makes you happy.
Yes, we went through this then. You were wrong then, which is why you are trying to move the goalposts now. This is about one season, 2022, when...
Exactly. He signed for relatively cheap backup money. He knew he wasn't Plan A.
You are looking at what Smith's cap hit would have been for 2025 if the Steelers hadn't cut him loose, not what they paid him last season.
Nobody thought or thinks you were saying that Marino was terrible. Sure, trying to dismiss all statistical evidence as "peripheral bs" is...
I did provide an answer for the claim about Aikman making players around him better. I disproved it in the case of Smith, who led the league in...
LOL. That thought popped into my head as well, but I can't see either team doing it.
There is risk throwing over the middle, but the offense is too easy to defend if you don't do it often enough. I still think they told Pickett to...
Your argument is based in this foolish notion that quarterbacks control everything going on around them. They don't. The teams around them matter.
You are playing fast and loose with the term fact. Marino and Johnson did clash over play calling, but that doesn't come close to supporting your...
It is a hell of a lot easier to produce at the right times when you have a dominant offensive line in front of you and one of the best running...
The strike-year team that made the Super Bowl in 1982 had a dominant defense. The team that made it there with Marino in 1984 still had a good...
You aren't wrong. I don't think they steered Wilson away from the middle of the field because Tomlin put his trust in the guy. Unfortunately, he...
Nice try. There is nothing else to get. You made a claim that doesn't align with the facts, and this is the way you chose to address it. There are...
I already got it. I asked you politely not to try to prop up your poor argument by claiming ignorance in others. Please don't do that. Thank you.
We are having a discussion. We disagree. Until you implied that I didn't understand your argument when I do, we were doing it in an entirely civil...
You argued that the difference was Aikman playing for a three-time championship team. The only factor in Aikman's favor is team success. By every...
Then no, we are not reacting to something different from the question you were asked. We are reacting to a response to the question of who was...
When you respond by making a claim that differs from someone else, you are arguing. You are judging the two quarterbacks based on things outside...
Explain how statistics mean nothing in evaluating a quarterback? That makes no sense unless you are trying to dismiss statistics because they make...
