Overturned sideline catch?

Does anyone have the footage of the overturned catch by Claypool? I was interrupted for a second but I swear he got both feet down "clearly" because he rolled his foot over the defenders foot and tapped his toe?

I came back and saw that it was overturned?

 

the second foot came down on the defender and he was touching out of bounds.

 

Man, if the call was overturned because Claypools toe touched at the same time the defenders knee touched out of bounds.....which is what it looks like.....that is still a bad overturn.

I just watched it in slo-mo and Claypools hand touched out of bounds just before his toe touched.

 

Yep.



Ron Torbert has had some real stinkers thus far this season. Yesterday's game was by far his worst.

 

It was a good call.

his second foot never touched the ground until he was out of bounds. I rewatched it a bunch then listened to the explanation by the official type guest.

 

Yeah, it wasn't that his foot came down on the defender when the defender was out because that happened almost simultaneously, it was that his hand touched out of bounds just before his toe touched.

 

exactly. Sucks, but they got it right this time

 

Yeah, it was the right call for sure, unfortunately. I was actually surprised that it was originally ruled as a catch.

 

This was the right call, BUT the offensive pass interference call on Claypool was horrible, he barley touched the defender if he even did touch him. That would of been his 5th touchdown.

 

Horrible call but I think he stepped out right after the catch?

 

Looked like it

 

Even if he did, it was a 30 yard-ish completion at that point. Instead, 2 plays later, Ebron fumbles. I would have been fine with him stepping out of bounds, considering the alternative.

 

I am often amazed at how these guys can concentrate so deeply on multiple things at once.

1. Making an extremely difficult catch.
2. Holding on to the ball.
3. Getting both feet in bounds.
4. Turning that toe to make it touch the ground.

Utterly fascinating!

 

Easy...they just think about our 4-0 record, close their eyes, and it all works out.

That's what @steelersrule6 does just before he gets lucky with himself.

 

He stepped out of bounds. It wasn't going to be a touchdown. Also, it would have been his fourth score at that point.

That said, it was a horrible call.

The funny thing to me about Claypool's sideline catch that was overturned was that I was convinced it should be an incomplete pass as soon as I saw a replay. My brother, an Eagles fan, thought it should remain a catch.

 

Really wasn't looking if he stepped out of bounds after the catch, that said if surly was a horrible call. I don't know how a ref can make that call. The defender fell down on his own without any contact that I could see.