Steelers and Sam Darnold

Because it only makes sense to say that McVay can teach a rookie Qb greatly if we actually see him coach a rookie Qb. Why is this hard to understand???

 

So what your saying is ?

 

It don't matter since McVay has proved he could coach a very young QB who had a historic bad rookie season under Jeff Fisher and he has been in the super bowl 2 years later with the same QB.The rookie thing is a very dumb thing,you just try too hard to fit your argument

 

Yet he hasn't proved he could coach a rookie. I know you love him, but he hasn't proved that yet.
I think he's a great HC, but that doesn't mean he can coach up a rookie Qb. We have never seen it. You can live off of guessing, I like to actually see it.

 

The rookie thing is such meaningless criteria especially he's never had a rookie QB, so that criteria makes no sense.

 

LoL. Yeah real meaningless when You say a guy can do it. LoL. Grow up. If You say You can run a 4.32 forty. I need to see it, not You pointing to a 4.40, and saying see. A 4.40 forty is not a 4.32 forty, and a Qb that has already been in the NFL a year, and has played is not a rookie the next year. How is this so hard for you to understand. Geez. You act like this is rocket science, or music theory.

 

Your point make no sense.And the job Sean McVay has done since he joined the Rams speaks for itself... The rest, like your criteria for fitting the argument, is just noise

The job he did with Goff is more impressive than many jobs other head coaches have done with a rookie who had a great rookie season, since Goff's confidence was gone after 2016 and McVay did an incredible job rebuilding his confidence and getting to the Super Bowl two years later with him...

 

Didn't read. Again you are not answering the question. Name Me a rookie Qb McVay as a HC has developed. Until you do, You cannot say he can, just like I can't say he can't, but I can definitely say I've never seen it while You can just guess.
Nobody is saying he is not a good HC. Yet this is somehow difficult for you. LoL

 

don't matter,rookie or not

 

LoL. So the answer is no he has never coached up a rookie QB as a HC. It's pretty simple to say instead of arguing. LoL.
I know you want things to be they way you want to think things are,but at some point you have to grow up, and see things for what really has been.
McVay is a great HC. McVay has made Qbs look better, but we have never seen McVay coach up a rookie Qb. It's pretty simple.

 

Because he never had the opportunity... But reviving Goff's career after a historic bad rookie season is a great accomplishment... He doesn't need to prove he can coach a rookie QB, but if he does this in the future, I guarantee you'll change the standards again.

 

LoL. LoL. LoL. No he doesn't need to . He is still a great HC, but to say that he can coach a rookie Qb up for a fact, you need to actually have done it. Somehow this is eluding you. LoL.

 

Why this is so important for you?

 

Because people said he can with no proof he can. Why is it so important to you to argue he can when You have never seen it??? Mine is based off of proof, yours is based off of what You want to believe.
I never said he couldn't, I said I, and nobody else has ever seen him do it. Notice I have never said this about HCs I actually know that has. Why because we've seen it. We are not guessing.

 

You keep making things up and presenting your opinions as facts because you hate the guy. Shrugs.

 

You do know you are basing this entirely on unconfirmed reports that were probably leaks from the team trying to save face after its brutal mishandling of a first-round quarterback, right?

 

Exactly, but some of the fanboys here can't admit that. They need to scapegoat Pickett rather than admit he could have succeeded in a better system, but had no shot with Tomlin and Canada.

 

Now you are just looking foolish

 

Still repeating that lie even after I presented receipts?

 

Give me a hint

What part of the easy to verify facts are you not comprehending

 

The system had nothing to do with Pickett failing he's just not a starting QB, would McVay or Reid have made Pickett a starting type of QB I doubt it.

 

I'm not even sure if he's a serviceable back-up QB at this point.

 

Kenny has failed to succeed with four teams now. It wasn't going to happen if he had Bill Walsh as HC.