Patrick Graham - DC

I agree, but I believe he was a HOF player
also.

 

Yeah, but what great offensive or defensive mind didn't? He had both great players and great defenses. In Cincy he struggled because he didn't have very many good players, therefore he didn't have very many good defenses...

I am excited to see what Graham can do with some talent.

 

Sorry , I meant that He (Lebeau) was a HOF player when he played.

 

I'm trying the not pour cold water on everything but I've not heard McCarthy say a peep about analytics before. Now he's supposedly all about AI and analytics. He says ANYTHING to get a job and a smooth runway. Then he does same old stuff. He basically runs Mike Holmgen's offense. Despite Mike's claims that he updated everything in his year in exile, he showed up in Dallas running the same stuff.

But if you thought Steelers challenges and timeouts were wild during the Tomlin tenure, wait till you see Mike wield the challenge flag. Or 4th down decisions.

That's what is so frustrating about it all. The franchise had a chance to bring in new blood and fresh thinking to blend with the institutional knowledge that was working. Instead they brought in the best state if the art ideas from 1995.

 

Steelers have screwed up the defense worse than the offense the last decade. This with the supposed "defensive" head coach.

The Steelers wasted the greatest offensive era in their franchises history between 2012-2018. So wasted, that had they just had a decent defense, they may have won a Super Bowl or two. They couldn't even get to one.

They spent over 100 million on the defense this year and lost again because of the inability to stop 3rd down conversions all year and getting run by the Joe Flacco's of the world and being the only team all year in Week 1 where Justin Fields looked like a coherant NFL QB.

Just one bludder after another and now it's theboff season and "hope" again starts and optimism reigns because we want it to work.


Sorry, not gonna buy it. Hiring Graham was a horrible hire and now we are gonna have to continue to read messages on here next year about how bad the defense is.

 

Ah, my bad lol I misunderstood your comment

 

At least we're used to it lol the challenges and timeouts are going to be an issue I guess... They were before... Its something I hope he's improved

I agree with the last part to a degree for sure, but McCarthy has had a good offense as recent as a few years ago. I think his system works a lot better in today's game than Tomlin's defensive system has in recent years. I wonder how bad it could have gotten had we not had exceptional defensive talent over the years.

 

But the main reason you didn't like it (according to the previous post) was because he coached for a bottom feeder franchise... Now you don't like him because Tomlin screwed up the defense? I'm having a hard time following all of this... none of it makes any logical sense.

I agree with the failings of the previous regime (particularly on Tomlin's defense). It was one of the main reasons I have been calling for him to be fired for a couple years now. But how on earth does that have anything to do with Graham? The things you claim to want (a guy who has average success with bad talent) is exactly what were getting... your reasoning for Graham being a "horrible" hire just don't check out. It doesn't mean he's going to be good either, its just... how are we this down on Graham. I think with the options available to us, its a pretty good hire.

I'm not just sayin "optimism" because I want it to work. I am simply looking at what the facts are at this moment in time. We don't know what Graham is going to want to do because its been slightly different in each stint he's had... but I don't want to label it a bad hire because he isn't a brand new DC or because he was DC for a dumpster franchise before us... I think having as negative feelings of the hire as you have is a bit shortsighted, even if you're entitled to that opinion.

 

I want to be dead wrong on this. I hope I am. Winning is more important than being right in this scenario.

 

Agreed. I can't imagine the Steelers wouldn't make Porter a priority.

 

I agree. Graham could turn out to be a bad decision in the end... I don't think he's bad enough to write him off before he even steps on the field in Steelers gear.

 

No problem, my explanation wasn't very good.