Pickett ranked worst first rd QB in last 5 years

Agreed, when was the last time the Steelers picked up a 5th year option?

 

Pickett threw a pretty good deep ball at Pitt (had two great WR's), but it never translated well in the pros. But yes, everything else was average or below average. It was a reach for the Steelers to draft him in the 1st round, and unfortunately it didn't work out. I'd be surprised if he's still in the league next year.

 

There is no way a QB drafted in the top 5 is “better” than a QB drafted in the 20’s if franchises give up on both.

I think the reason Kenny is in the discussion is because folks thought the Steelers were a QB away from glory and expectations were high. Yet we often handcuffed Kenny until the 4th quarter.

I was a huge Pitt/ Pickett fan so I have time when it comes to Kenny. He didn’t pan out but we just watched Aaron Rodgers put up 6 points in a playoff game. The offense was inept under Tomlin and company and if we invested in the offense like we invested in defense maybe we have more success.

I’ll say this.. go back to the Raiders game, both Baltimore games and even the Miami game that we lost. Kenny showed flashes when we opened the offense up.

Buffalo invested in Josh Allen and gave him weapons after his first few years. What did the Steelers invest in on offense? We shipped Pickens out of town and he was a top 5 WR. We brought in DK who is also a head case. My frustration with the FO was giving the D the world but the offense was treated like an afterthought.

 

Pickett had a weak arm, horrible pocket presence, couldn't scramble, etc. He was just not talented, and he had the least amount of talent compared to the other QBs on the list which is the criteria for the article.

Its a good thing Steelers didn't invest in the offense and moved on from Pickett when they did. Had they just had a tiny bit more success, we'd likely still be saddled with Pickett.

 

He's nowhere near, look at Zach Wilson.

 

If multiple draft picks are given up to get a 1st round Qb, and they are still a backup, I don't see how a guy taken later in that round for nothing but that pick could be worse.
If neither one of you are playing.....the one that more was given up for must be worse.

 

This thread, well, is something else.
The idea of Pickett as the worst QB has to be filtered by 'the last 5 years.' which is just terrible.

So here we go.
First and foremost, Kenny Pickett was supposed to be 'project' despite what some have said here.
Bad decision #1: Big Ben was out of gas the last 2 years for sure. I don't care if he whined if I draft a QB. It was obvious Mason wasn't the guy. They passed.
Bad decision #2: Omar and Colbert(handing over the torch) had that in mind. This while thinking Mitch Trubisky could mentor him in.
Bad decision #3: They trot him out on the field week 4 after Mitch produced exactly nothing, they kind of did the right thing as Pickette threw 13 times for 120 yards and rushed for 2 TDs. Bad news is, he threw 3 picks.
Bad Decision #4: They name him the starter for a game against the Bills. Our genius Offensive Coordinator, Matt F@#$king Canada, has him dropping back 51 times! Result a whopping from the Bills 38-3.....
Bad Decision #5: Etc..... and the concussions start. Matt Canada's offense was unwatchable.
Bad Decision #6 Pickett missed some games... but again came back and provided some last minute heroics with some late wins. What's wrong with that? Well he's a twice concussed rookie project QB who even if upper tier would provide highs and lows... the offense did not adjust Nothing changed.
The good? He became the first rookie to throw game winning TDs for 2 games. He has a game ball in the HoF too.

Bad Decision #7: Still no WRs that break open games. Pickett was here but Canada didn't know how to work him.
Bad Decision #8 -20: Keeping Matt Canada.
Bad Decision #21: Not sticking with the "clerical error" and named Mason #2 and let Kenny earn what he earned which may be nothing or maybe more. In not doing so, they gave the false security of being the Steelers QB. Darn right he was upset when old man Wilson showed up. Even though year two was terrible for Pickett, Canada was supposed to get the best from him, he couldn't even get the best from his offense.

There were other bad decisions. The entire thing was toxic lending credence to dimwits that don't know a QB from a mountain goat let alone a colossal string of utterly terrible decisions. I wish I had magical powers to impress on some just how God-awful Matt Canada was.... I literally had a colleague seek me out in the press box to remind me that I left Washington for this... pointing out Matt Canada's terrible offense.

It's all water under the bridge. The coaching has changed and there's probably going to be a lot of new faces. I can't worry about Kenny Pickett, he has to write his own story. My gut feeling is that unless he can get on the Rams, or 49ers, maybe the Vikings, his career is as a backup or maybe over.
I do hope Howard has a better shot.
And any future QB, I am really skeptical that Omar will produce anything. I want to be wrong.

 

Good post ^

 

do they? I know Richardson killed it in shorts at the combine but anyone who watched him at Florida knew he was TERRIBLE and clammed up anytime he had an INT or bad throw.

What talent does Trey Lance have? He has 5TD’s and 2 INTs in his NFL career.

 

I looked up to see where Matt Canada landed after getting fired from the Steelers and the answer is nowhere. He is now entering his 3rd year of unemployment.

 

Not even a high school team will hire him, lol.

 

The

guy probably made more than $10M

 

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/N6s5rwMd2_o?feature=share