Who will be the Steelers starting QB in the 2026 season opener?

Donny Football is on 93.7 the Fan. He's the one that broke the news about Tomlin stepping down. He's been very critical of the McCarthy hiring and the possibility of Rodgers returning. So he was saying today that his Steeler contact told him to shut up about it and like it because "Rodgers is coming back period."

 

It is very realistic if you could realize I'm talking about right now today. Today there are only 2 QBs with contracts for next season. A 2-man QB room. That's so that's in there. I've run out of ways to explain it. You're just thick.

 

This is the post @Steelvision is arguing with.

 

He also struggled in 2024
Last good season was 2023

 

and your an idiot and no way in hell they go into the season with just MR, Howard and TC fodder.

 

And there's the proof

 

I wonder if Will Howard will give up #18 for the starter Kirk Cousins.

 

Donny Football originally gave the McCarthy hiring a F
He upgraded it to a F+

 

Come on my guy
No sense to get personal
Disagree and move on
Peace

 

It's all on reading comprehension disability

 

I understand you perfectly, your premise doesnt make any sense. I already gave a rational response and you resort to name calling and trying to cry to other posters as a reaction. Im done with this back and forth. fire away with more retorts in any form if you like, i dont care.

 

McCarthy may just be the guy to find and develop our next franchise Qb, that mightve been the whole purpose, not to be the next long term coach like his predecessors. But to fastrack the rebuild/keep the team competitive, then hand a playoff team off to the next guy. We wont have to wait another 20 years, and rely on FA’s and late draft picks, gotta trust the Rooneys. As a fan of a few decades i should know better

 

I understood him

And I understand that you did not

And your irrelevant response confirmed this

So your rude behavior was inappropriate

 

Mike McCarthy has identified a franchise QB zero times in his career.

Montana
Favre
Rodgers
Prescott

All were already on the roster before his arrival. Rodgers was drafted a full season before McCarthy came. McCarthy was also some portion of the decision making team that picked Alex Smith over Rodgers.

We do have evidence that McCarthy helped improve and refine Rodgers mechanics and footwork. It may be that McCarthy was able to coach the "Tedford" out of Rodgers. https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft05/columns/story?columnist=pasquarelli_len&id=2039797

But we all need to stop unquestiongly buying the Mike McCarthy QB guru hype. That hype is largely part of his own promotion machine. Mike McCarthy is incredibly effective at promoting Mike McCarthy

It's possible that McCarthy comes in and pushes Howard or some other young QB to the top of the heap. But, please, stop viewing this as a guaranteed result. The track record is not there.

 

It's possible McCarthy is very good at developing quarterbacks, but he shouldn't be the one choosing the quarterback!

He deserves some credit for developing Rodgers, since Rodgers was far from a sure thing in 2006... Brett Favre had an improbable great year in 2007 after a terrible 2005 season and a very average 2006 season.

Cooper Rush was able to have a winning record in over 10 starts in Dallas under McCarthy... He was a total scrub in Baltimore in 2025... So we can say that McCarthy is able to get the best out of his QBs if they are NFL-caliber QBs and not Brett Hundley-type quarterbacks where he had no business to be in the NFL!

 

Sucks for the Pittsburgh Steelers.

 

It makes no sense to bring A-Rod back. If they do, it's just another wasted year before we find a franchise Qb

I get Howard is a 6th rounder, but have we even seen him play a down? With good guidence and coaching I think he could be good.

Then again he could stink, but that's something we'll never know if they don't play him. I like his attitude and competitivness

 

i understood him too, and i said it was unrealistic imo and he got snippy and he was the one who began throwing out names, and i threw one back. So get your understanding straight jeh.

 

It was never going to be anyone else but AR, from the moment Fredo said "We 'aint rebuilding".

The question is to ask is, are we going to do this again in '27?, because '25 was supposed to be the last ride...