Are Saquon Barkley and Christian McCaffrey hall of famers?

Are Saquon Barkley and Christian McCaffrey hall of famers?

For comparison purposes:

Terrell Davis
7 years, 7,607 rushing yards, 60 TDs, 4.6 ypc, 8,887 yards from scrimmage

Saquon Barkley
8 years, 8,356 rushing yards, 55 TDs, 4.6 ypc, 11,007 yards from scrimmage

Christian McCaffrey
9 years, 7,589 rushing yards, 62 TDs, 4.6 ypc, 12,979 yards from scrimmage

 

I'm going to say yes for both.

 

not sure bout dosguys but

MIKE TOMLIN IS

 

Barkley is close and yes for CMC

 

If NFL HOF was like the Rock and Roll HOF everybody would eventually make it

 

Based off those stats only, yes.

Davis also won the NFL MVP in 1998. He won 2 Super Bowls with one SB MVP. Davis was a 3-time First Team All Pro. And won OPoY twice in those 7 years.


I think Barkley and McCaffrey are both top notch RBs and maybe worthy of the HoF. But Terrell Davis was definitely worthy of the HoF. Just my opinion.

 

CMC yes.

 

If you have to ask, they ain’t.

 

So my opinion is the final word on the matter. Good to know. I didn't know I had that kind of power. I'm not that self-absorbed that I don't value others opinions.

 

Other’s opinions is usually emotional, which means nothing to me. It’s how I’ve done well in my life and live without issues on a daily basis.

 

Wow! I took his response to mean if they aren't clearly in the Hall, probably means they don't deserve the Hall. Maybe I misinterpreted?

 

Yes they will be. Neiter man in finshed plaing football yet so thier stats will only get better.

 

No for Barkely. Yes for McCaffrey.


Neither currently crack the Top 15 and sure as hell dont even come close to Top 10 Running Backs ever.