The most overrated player in the NFL is

Justin Herbert 0-3 in the playoffs

 

I felt bad for him tonight he was absolutely hammered every time he touched the ball.

 

He had been great this year with a depleted offensive line and bad OC but yeah come playoffs time,he is awful

 

The loss isn't all on Herbert his OL was awful, but throwing passes where your receivers don't have a chance to make a play and not getting the ball to McConkey is bad.

 

They need to get rid of Roman as OC his offense has no creativity at all.

 

The chargers were also 20th in PPG on offense this year.3 points last night....Roman is gone for sure.Lamar Jackson was back to back first team all pro in 2023 and 2024 after he was gone

 

This game was a paradox for me. PTSD from too many cheater victories had me rooting for the Chargers. Then they would show Harbaugh on the sidelines and I would immediately be rooting for the Patriots.


I just went to bed.

 

OMG. You can't have it both ways. You can't say it's all a Qb when it's Josh Allen, but when it's a different Qb it's the coaches. LoL. Can You say Hypocrite???

 

Trevor Lawerence.

 

The most overrated player in the NFL?


Arch Manning


But seriously, Justin Herbert has to be high on the list. This season he has a revolving OL so maybe he gets a break. But for the record, total collapse in 3 playoff games. Jags, Texans, and Patriots all made him look like he doesn't belong in the post season.

 

It was on Fox Sports today that the 2 QB's with the lowest QB rating in playoff history at a minimum of 3 games are Andy Dalton and Justin Herbert.

 

It's like @santeesteel always says!


SAN DIEGO... SUPER CHARGERS!!!

 

You just made me vomit! Happy?
I never said that even when I was a fan..........at 14 y.o. Of course, that was before they came up with that disco nonsense!

 

Joe Burrrow. Hard to be great when you are constantly on the sidelines with some sort of obscure injury.

 

Just teasing ya!!!


I know that is not your favorite team. Figured though that the point you made to me when we first conversed wasn't forgotten.

 

On the subject of Justin Herbert though?! I wrote him off as a Top 10 QB after his Jacksonville debacle in 2022; as did others. Emmanuel Acho though seems to be pretty elated about his take that has seemingly aged well.


Overall?! Justin Herbert is tied with the Colts' Bert Jones, Patriots' Steve Grogan, and Saints' Bobby Hebert for being 0-3 as a Starter. Only the Bengals' Andy Dalton and Giants and 49ers' YA Tittle are worse at 0-4.

 

If Herbert was a free agent, teams would be lining up to hire him.


For most overrated players in the NFL, CJ Stroud is trending that way. So is Lamar Jackson.

2025 vs. 2024 production.

 

It is a shame he can't stay healthy, and a shame the Bungles don't improve their OL to keep him healthy.

 

Stroud or Tua in the cold weather have to be the leagues worst "Franchise" QBs.

 

Bengals screwed up what could have been a top tier franchise QB. Then again his injury bug doesn't help.

 

Lamar Jackson has won two MVPs and I wouldn't vote for him for the hall of Fame.