Ugh…Purdy or Pickett

Eli that 2nd run still holds the record for the most passing yards in a single postseason .

 

Hurts doesn't have to match Mahomes. That's the part you don't understand. The Eagles have the superior running game. They have the superior defense, including the league's best pass rush. You still don't seem to get that his isn't one-on-one.

I'm aware that you have had a low opinion of Pickett all along. I'm also aware that you don't actually understand what goes into making an outstanding quarterback, so I have little respect for your opinion on the matter.

 

There haven't been many blowout Super Bowls. Bears vs. Patriots, Broncos vs. Redskins and 49ers vs. Chargers are ones I can remember.

 

One game can demonstrate how something is possible. We see games all the time in which the team with the lesser quarterback wins. I gave you one example from this season involving the Steelers.

I never said the Steelers are winning a Super Bowl that way, though it's not impossible. Pickett is going to have to get better for them to be real contenders.

Evaluating an entire team, or even a defensive unit, based on one game is foolish. This is especially true when you don't even realize that the unit in question was missing some key guys.

 

Only if you don’t want to look like a moron

 

He also has a narrative that he is committed to and he won't be backing down anytime soon regardless of how idiotic he sounds.

 

Pickett vs. Purdy

Jury still out, give me another year of viewing

 

It could have been Pickett and Purdy. Every team in the NFL passed on Purdy many times, including the 49ers. They didn't know he could do what he did as a rookie, either.

The shame is that the Steelers wasted their seventh-round pick on a quarterback and never even let him on the field in preseason when they could have used it on Purdy.

Ultimately, I think Pickett will be better, but they certainly would have been better off with both.

 

I guess we are saying then that TB12 did not have monster contracts?

as a % of that years salary cap, he was always Top 5 or so (I think - I know we always say he took less - and he did, but he made tens of millions....) , so I would call that monster.....and they kept winning with him. He was transcendent.

Manning in 2016. Top paid QB.

more than not, big price paid QB's are the ones winning.

 

Read much???
I said Unanimously...., but instead of actually reading....You instantly got butt hurt....., and just like that....is the same reason He got Unanimous MVP. LoL.

 

See. Now read back what You just wrote....use some intelligence, and see How that backs what I said. A reporter didn't want to give it to a Guy that crushed every single record, but they Unanimously wanted to give it to a Guy that had 13 less td, and less yards rushing, and passing added together...than Manning had just passing. Yeah....LoL .

 

Seahawks/Denver

 

Mahomes signed a very team friendly deal also.

 

Not true. You should look again. P. Manning was when He went to a already made team....like Stafford, and like the Rams are, and will be still paying for it.
Brady has been about middle of the pact in most years of Qb cap hit.....except for His very 1st pay day...., and when He left, and went to Tampa. @Blast Furnace was talking about on original team I believe, and He is correct.
I have left a Qbs ,SBs, and their cap Hit on Here before when this has been brought up, and what Blast said in mainly true. I will not dig it all up again.

 

i understand.
but Manning was making Top $$, yes - he went to a loaded team, kind of like Brady did with Tampa

I did not know TB12 stayed middle of the pack over the years, was thinking he was still top 5 all those years. I was mistaken, then.

 

It's cool. I wasn't arguing....I was just conversing about it.

 

Well, 8-8 seems to be the acceptable standard for the STEELERS so a 9-win season is a plus.

 

Remember those SB's the Bills loss? One was close, the other ones the Cowgirls smoked them in two of them. Can't remember the other one but I think it was a boring game.

 

They lost to the Redskins by 13 in the other one. The only one that was close was their first appearance, the one-point loss to the Giants.

 

Be careful agreeing with Huey

That's a stink you can’t wash off

Kind of like SNOT

 

Forgot about that one. I quit watching after 1st half. I was glad Seahawks won.

 

Why couldn't #7 done this for his last 6 years?